Time for a Superannuation Checkup?
Critical Condition for some Super Funds

Time for a Superannuation Health Check?
Australia's superannuation landscape recently underwent a significant health check by the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA). The results? Some alarming findings that might have you reassessing where your retirement savings are placed.
The Diagnosis: Critical Condition for Some
At least 1 million Australians are members of superannuation funds that barely passed APRA's inaugural performance test. Worse yet, some would have failed if they had been included in this test. Among these funds is Rest Super, a behemoth in the industry with a value of $67 billion, which only managed to scrape through by a whisker.
The Underperformers
APRA's assessments classified Rest's default product as "poor performing" with deteriorating investment returns. The results from 2018-2021 were notably worse than those from 2014-2021. But Rest Super wasn't alone in this precarious position. Others that barely passed the test include TWU Super's Balanced option, a fund for Westpac staff administered by BT, Mine Super's default product, and a few more. These seven products collectively hold a whopping $78 billion in members' retirement savings.
APRA's Super Heat Map
In a bid to make the superannuation industry more transparent, APRA released its annual superannuation fund heat map. This provides a comprehensive look at how different funds performed in the inaugural performance test in August. The test itself examined the performance of default superannuation products over seven years, identifying those that delivered returns more than 0.5 percentage points below their net return benchmark. Thirteen funds didn't clear their benchmarks.
It's also worth noting that an additional 115 "choice" investment options, not included in this year's test, underperformed by more than 0.5 percentage points below their benchmark. APRA's findings suggest that choice investment options often delivered worse outcomes than default products, with 60% failing to meet their seven-year target.
The Sector's Underperformers
Digging deeper, the heat map also highlighted a few superannuation trustees, such as BT Super and Aware Super, as having a high concentration of these underperforming choice options. EISS Super, Australian Catholic Super, Christian Super, Zurich, OnePath, and Perpetual were also spotlighted for their choice products' "significantly poor returns".
The Road to Recovery
With over $3.4 trillion in the sector, it's crucial for these funds to be held accountable. APRA's focus on performance has shown results, with 22 default products closing since the first heat map was published in December 2019. APRA's superannuation chief, Margaret Cole, emphasised the need for better supervision of trustees of products that aren't delivering for their members. She remarked, "Superannuation members deserve confidence that their retirement savings are being well looked after."
Conclusion
The health of our superannuation funds is pivotal for a secure retirement. With such revelations from APRA, it's more critical than ever to review and, if necessary, reconsider where our hard-earned money is invested. Ensure your super isn't in critical condition. It might just be time for a check-up.










